Mousing Around

Use Scooter the Snail with Ooze Touch and Dive, Rapana Whelk with Absorb, Shell Shield, and Dive, and Red Cricket with Skitter, Cocoon Strike, and Nature's Touch. Open with Scooter and spam Ooze Touch, then Dive. After Scooter falls, bring in Red Cricket and rotate Cocoon Strike, Skitter, Skitter, Nature's Touch. Once Red Cricket falls, finish with Rapana Whelk using Shell Shield followed by Absorb and Dive.

Robert Craig uses all Beast pets. Start with Rapana Whelk against Thrugtusk: use Shell Shield immediately, then spam Absorb, refreshing Shell Shield when it has one round remaining. Use Dive to finish Thrugtusk when low. When Wumpas appears, swap to Pygmy Cow. Alternatively, three S/S Rabbits all with the 2-2-2 moveset can work: open with Dodge, then Stampede, then Flurry, using Dodge on cooldown and Stampede to maintain its debuff.

Use an S/S Rabbit with the 2-2-1 moveset, a Fire Beetle with the 1-2-1 moveset, and a Rapana Whelk with the 1-2-1 moveset. Open with Rabbit: Dodge, Flurry, Flurry, then Burrow on rounds 4-5, Flurry to kill the Spirit Guide, and Dodge during the resurrection round. When Quinillo enters, Flurry until Rabbit dies, swap to Fire Beetle, use Scorched Earth, then Burn until Quinillo dies. When Fethyr enters, swap to Rapana Whelk, use Shell Shield, then Ooze Touch, refreshing Shell Shield on cooldown. Bring Fire Beetle back in if needed: Cauterize, Scorched Earth, then Burn.

Defeat the remaining Broken Isles Master Tamers using only Critter pets to reach the required total of 12.