Now We're Cookin'

Visit the cooking trainer outside Stormwind City (available during the Pilgrim's Bounty event) to learn Cooking, and buy Simple Flour and Mild Spices from the nearby Pilgrim's Bounty ingredient vendor. Cook at least 80 Spice Bread to raise your cooking skill — the recipe goes gray at 40 but still grants skill-ups, and you'll need the bread for a later recipe.

Buy the Bountiful Cookbook from a Pilgrim's Bounty recipe vendor for 1 silver and learn all the holiday recipes inside, including Spice Bread Stuffing and the remaining Pilgrim's Bounty dishes.

Purchase most required ingredients — such as Teldrassil Sweet Potato (Alliance) or Mulgore Sweet Potato (Horde), Ripe Elwynn Pumpkin or Ripe Tirisfal Pumpkin, and Tangy Wetland Cranberries or Tangy Southfury Cranberries — from Pilgrim's Bounty vendors outside capital cities, using the item's name and flavor text to identify the correct vendor location.

Obtain Wild Turkey by killing Wild Turkeys in Elwynn Forest (Alliance) or Tirisfal Glades (Horde), as this ingredient is not sold by vendors and must be looted directly.

With a minimum cooking skill of 280 required for the highest recipe, cook all five Pilgrim's Bounty dishes — Slow-Roasted Turkey, Pumpkin Pie, Cranberry Chutney, Candied Sweet Potato, and Spice Bread Stuffing — to complete the achievement. Remember to train each cooking rank (at skill levels 50, 125, 200, and 275) so you do not waste skill gains.